HELP!!

Hi everyone :)

Please HELP!!
Ros from Sew Delicious has organised a winter sewing day...AND I'M GOING :)
I know that I want to make myself a bag...(mine broke a few weeks ago and I really NEED a new one :P)
So, I really need your help!

1 - Paisley pear "Nikki tote"

2 - Noodlehead "Super tote"

So what do you think? Which should I make?

Thanks!
Emma